1. Retail Package - Installation
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 1
released
its first 16X recordable drive, the DW1600A. At this recording
speed, a single
layer 4.75GB disc can now be recorded in a little less than six minutes. The
drive supports only DVD+R/+RW recording, but according to BenQ, a firmware
upgrade will be available in August 2004 to allow it to support DVD-R/-RW recording.
In addition, the drive features DVD+R Double Layer recording at a speed
of 2.4X, nearly doubling the capacity of recordable discs.
Although drive performance is an important point for all end users, writing
quality should be taken under consideration as well, especially at 16X recording
speed,
as more
16X DVD recording capable devices will hit the market soon. So, let's get down
to it...
- Drive Features
- Over-Speed burning technology (will be explained later
on this review).
- Seamless Link: buffer under run protection as all previous
BenQ DVD Recorders.
- High-Speed Signal Algorithm: As writing speed is increased,
signal loss becomes the key cause of a significant decrease in writing quality.
BenQ’s High-Speed Signal Algorithm manages the high EFM (Eight-to-Fourteen
Modulation) frequency signal loss that often takes place at high-speed writing
- ensuring superb writing quality.
- WOPC + BLER OPC: Unlike other drives which preset the
writing power before the actual writing of data, the WOPC II (Walking Optimal
Power Control) algorithm evaluates the writing quality constantly and adjusts
the writing power accordingly in order to ensure the best possible writing
quality over the entire disc. The BLER OPC (Block Error Rate Optimal Power
Control) further enhances the writing quality near the end of the disc, where
the risk of warping is higher.
- Tilt Control: BenQ's Tilt Control always keeps the writing
angle at 90 degrees on the disc surface to ensure uniform writing.
- Sliding Cone Mechanism: With Sliding Cone design, the
disc position on the turntable is improved considerably. This greatly helps
to reduce data access time and also to deliver superior reading and writing
quality.
- Specifications
Interface:
|
E-IDE/ATAPI (Ultra DMA Mode
2)
|
Writing Speed:
|
DVD+R: 16X, DVD+RW: 4X,
DVD+R DL: 2.4X
|
|
CD-R: 40X, CD-RW: 24X
|
Read Speed:
|
DVD+R/-R/+RW/-RW: 16X
max
|
|
DVD-ROM: 16X, CD-R/RW: 40X
|
Random Access:
|
DVD: 120msec, CD: 120msec
|
Buffer Size:
|
2MB
|
|
DVD: DVD+R DL 8.5GB,
DVD+R 4.7GB, DVD+RW 4.7GB, DVD-R 4.7GB (closed session), DVD-RW 4.7GB
(closed session), DVD-Video, DVD-5, DVD-9, DVD-10, DVD-18
|
|
CD-R/RW: CD-DA, CD-ROM
XA (m1, m2f1/m2f2), CD-R, CD-RW, Bootable CD, Photo CD (single & multi-session),
Video CD, Super Video CD, CD-Extra, Mixed-mode CD, CD-Text, CD-Graphics
|
Supported Writing Types:
|
DVD+RW: DVD Data and
Video
|
|
CD-R/RW:Track-at-Once, Disc-at-Once,
Multisession, Packet Writing (fixed & variable packet), CD Digital
Audio, Direct-Over-Write on CD-RW, Test Write |
The drive does not support Mount
Rainier and it uses the well known RPC II region control, allowing a user
to change the drive's region
at most 5 times. Below are the drive's main specs as given by NeroInfoTool.
VSO Inspector and DVDInfoPro:
- Tested Kit / Software Bundle
The package that arrived at our labs, included the BenQ DW16700A DL drive
along with Sonic RecordNow Burning Software, InterVideo WinCinema (WinDVD +
Win DVD
Creator)
DVD Authoring/Editing
Software
and BenQ's
QVideo 2.0 (easy DV, TV, AV to DVD). The BenQ Book Type Management v8.2 program
was also included to ensure media backward compatibility with older DVD players
(will be explained later on this review).
Now let's take a look at the drive itself.
We received the DW1600A DL drive with black-colored tray. BenQ claims that
dark-colored trays minimize jitters and enhance readability and burning quality.
The activity led lights up green when a disc is present, blinks
green when reading / accessing a disc and red when burning. On the front, the
user
will
distinguish the DVD+R DL logo.
On the rear panel you can see the analogue and digital outputs (SPDIF), the
IDE connector and the power input. Our drive was manufactured during May 2004
in Malaysia with SN #3.
Removing the screws and opening the drive's cover voids the drive's warranty.
For reference reasons, we post the following pictures. You can click on the
mainboard picture for a higher resolution image:
The heart of the drive is the Philip's Nexperia PNX7860 chipset.
- Installation
The drive was installed as secondary master and under WindowsXP was recognized
as "BENQ DVD DL DW1600". The drive arrived with
firmware revision B5A9 and since a newer firmware version
had been released, we flashed the drive with no problem to firmware revision B5B9,
and later to revision
B5C9. Newer firmware updates are expected to support more
media for 12X and 16X writing speeds.
Below is a screenshot of Nero Burning Rom, showing the drive's specs.
In this review, we will be comparing the drive with the Optorite DD0405 and
the LiteOn SOHW-832S.
- Testing software
In order to perform our tests we used:
- Nero CD-DVD Speed v3.01
- CDVD Benchmark v1.21
- ExactAudioCopy v0.9
beta5
- Nero Info Tool v2.21
- KProbe
v2.1.0 (Reader: LiteOn LDW-811S firmware vHS0Q, LiteOn SOHD-167T firmware
9S13, LiteOn XJ-HD165H firmware CH11, and LiteOn LTD-163 firmware GH5S,
Reading speed 8X CAV)
- PlexTools v2.14 (Reader:
Plextor PX-712A firmware v1.01, Reading speed 8X CLV for CD-R)
- DVDInfoPro v2.54
- Nero Burning Rom v6.3.1.15
- DVD Decrypter 3.2.2.0
- CopyToDVD 3.0.19.33
2. Transfer Rate Reading Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 2
Transfer Rate Reading Tests
- CD Format
The BenQ DW1600A DL supports up to 40X reading speed.
The DW1600A is faster than Optorite's drive, but cannot match
the LiteOn 832S when it comes to pressed CDs, with 31.52X average transfer
rate speed. Using CDR media, the drive performed as fast as the 832S, and
was again faster
than
the Optorite
DD0405.
Using US-RW media, DW1600A performed excellently and gave the
highest speed value among the three drives. The drive's maximum
speed is stated as 40X. It reached 41.58 in our tests, with
an overall average speed of 31.36X.
-DVD Format
The DW1600A can read PTP Single Layer DVD-ROM discs at 16X
CAV. The average read speed was 12.07, a great performance at this point.
The maximum speed achieved was 16.12X.
With a PTP DVD-ROM disc, the starting point of the two layers
is at the inner part of the disc. The drive reads from the beginning of each
layer (inner part) towards the outer part of the disc. The reported average
speed was slightly lower than the other two drives. Biggest speed difference
is reported when DW1600A is reading the outer parts of
the disc, at the end of each layer, with a speed of 8.07X (3~8CAV).
With an OTP Dual Layer disc, the first layer structure is the
same as the first layer on a PTP disc. The drive reads the first layer exactly
the same way as PTP discs, and with the same speed. The starting point of
the second layer of an OTP disc is located at the outer part of the disc.
The reported average speed was 6.05X (3~8CAV)
DW1600A reported similar speed results when reading single
layer -R/-RW and +R/+RW discs. Always slightly faster than LiteOn's drive
and slightly slower than Optorite's drive. But such differences in speed
are not worthy of notice (again 3~8CAV).
The DW1600A ripped a full dual layer DVD-Video disc with an
average speed of 8814kb/sec. Again, slightly faster than LiteOn's drive
and slightly slower than Optorite's drive.
-Appendix
Seek Times
Nero CD-DVD Speed Graphs
3. CD Error Correction Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 3
CD Error Correction
Tests
In the following tests we check the drive's behavior when it comes to reading
scratched / defective discs. The test discs we use are the ABEX series from
ALMEDIO.
Notice that the drive doesn't support C2 error information.
- ABEX TCD-721R
Errors total
|
Num: 1102682
|
Errors (Loudness) dB(A)
|
Num: 55429
|
Avg: -73.7 dB(A)
|
Max: -32.6 dB(A)
|
Error Muting Samples
|
Num: 3488
|
Avg: 1.3 Samples
|
Max: 537 Samples
|
Skips Samples
|
Num: 0
|
Avg: 0.0 Samples
|
Max: 0 Samples
|
Total Test Result
|
76.3 points (out of 100.0 maximum)
|
The DW1600A DL drive displayed quite good performance with this test disc.
The total error count (1102682) is about average, but the maximum error loudness
is very low at -32.6dB(A), as are the error loudness and muting sample counts,
while
there were no skipped samples. The final score of 76.3 is good.
- ABEX TCD-726
Errors total
|
Num: 21
|
Errors (Loudness) dB(A)
|
Num: 14
|
Avg: -86.2 dB(A)
|
Max: -74.9 dB(A)
|
Error Muting Samples
|
Num: 0
|
Avg: 0.0 Samples
|
Max: 0 Samples
|
Skips Samples
|
Num: 0
|
Avg: 0.0 Samples
|
Max: 0 Samples
|
Total Test Result
|
92.9 points (out of 100.0 maximum)
|
We observe great performance from the BenQ DW1600A DL with
the Abex TCD-726 test disc. The
total test result score of 92.9 points is very good.
- CD-Check Audio Test Disc
The CD-Check Test Disc is a very useful tool for evaluating the Sound Reproduction
/ Error correction capabilities of a CD player. The disc offers a signal combination
with disc error patterns to rate the drive's abilities to read music and reproduce
it completely. Five tracks on the disc contain a sequence of progressively
difficult tests. These tracks are referred as Check Level-1 through Check Level-5.
The files are reproduced (played) through a software multimedia player (i.e.
Windows Media Player). Each level is considered as passed, if the tone coming
out from the speakers is smooth, continuous without interruptions, skipping
or looping. The higher the Check Level passed, the more reliable the sound
reproduction of the tested device.
Error Level
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
BenQ DW1600A DL
|
5/5
|
5/5
|
5/5
|
5/5
|
2/5
|
The DW1600A passed 5 out of 5 plays for the first four Check Levels of the
test, while in the fifth level, it managed 2 out of 5. This is indicative of
very
good error correction capabilities. Very few drives ever manage to play up
to the fifth level.
- Conclusion
Combining the test scores from the ABEX discs, we get and average score of
84.6.
Rather good performance from BenQ's drive with our test discs.
4. DVD Error Correction Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 4
DVD Error Correction
Tests
In the following tests we examined the DVD reading capabilities of the BenQ
DW1600A DL drive
with scratched / defective DVD media. For
the tests we used CDVD Benchmark and Nero CDSpeed . The reference test media
comes from ALMEDIO.
- Single Layer media
ABEX TDR-821
This is a single sided, single layer DVD-ROM with a 4.7GB capacity, and its
surface has an artificial scratch of dimensions varying from 0.4 to 3.0 mm.
The following transfer rate picture comes from the CDVD Benchmark v1.21 transfer
rate test.
The DW1600A read the disc at 12X CAV. The scratched area did
not affect the reading process. The performance reveals good error correction
capabilities
with
scratched single layer DVD-ROM discs.
ABEX TDR-825
This
is also a single sided, single layer DVD-ROM of a 4.7GB capacity. The data
structure of the disc is exactly the same as that of the TDR-821, with the
difference that there are no scratches on it but defective areas of dimensions
ranging from 0.5 to 1.1 mm. There are also fingerprints sized between 65 and
75 micrometers.
Again, the drive read the disc without any read errors. Reading
speed was not reduced when the drive read the defective areas.
- Dual Layer media
ABEX TDR-841
This is an 8.5GB dual layer, single sided DVD-ROM disc with artificial scratches
of dimensions ranging from 0.4 to 3.0mm, on both layers.
There were no errors during the reading process. However, when
reading over the scratched areas, we observe a dense patch as the drive made
numerous speed changes to compensate for the defects.
ABEX TDR-845
The disc is a single sided, dual layer DVD-ROM disc of a capacity of 8.5GB.
The only difference between the TDR-845 and the TDR-841 is that the first includes
defective areas and fingerprints. The dimensions of the defective areas range
from 0.5 to 1.1 mm and the fingerprints are sized from 65 to 75 micro meters.
The drive did not have any problem reading TDR-845 test disc.
ABEX TDV-541
The
TDV-541 is a single sided, dual layer DVD-VIDEO disc, with a capacity of
8.5GB.The disc is based upon the TDV-540 series which is designed for inspection
and adjustment of DVD-VIDEO players. The discs check the layer switch operation
from layer 0 to layer 1 and also include test pictures and test signals for
DVD sound files. The current TDV-541 checks also the error correcting capabilities
of the drive and includes scratches from 0.4 to 3.0 mm.
Reading process started at 3.35X and smoothly increased
while reading the first layer, reaching 8.07X when reading the outer part
of the disc.The drive read both layers without reporting any read errors,
and reached an average speed of 6.05X.
ABEX TDV-545
The
TDV-545 disc is based on the TDV-540 series. It is a single sided, dual layer
DVD-VIDEO disc with a capacity of 8.5GB. The TDV-545 includes artificial black
dots on the data surface, sized from 0.4 to 1.0 mm. It has also 65 - 75 micro
meter fingerprints.
The DW1600A showed exact same behavior here as it did with
TDV-541 test disc. Even
the average speed and the starting speed were the same as before. It managed
to read the disc without any errors.
Very good
performance from the BenQ drive.
5. Protected Disc Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 5
Protected Disc
Tests
- Reading Tests
To create the image of the various protected titles to the hard disk, we
used Alcohol 120% software and the appropriate settings, according to the protection
type of the inserted discs. Below you can see the duration of each process
as well as the transfer rate in each case.
Game Title
|
Protection Scheme
|
Duration
|
Reading speed
|
PSX "NBA Jam Extreme"
|
Lybcrypt
|
00:58 min
|
1558 sectors/sec
|
Serious Sam The Second Encounter v1.07
|
SafeDisc v.2.60.052
|
44:35 min
|
125.3 sectors/sec
|
VRally II
|
SecuROM v.2
|
2:46 min
|
2070 sectors/sec
|
The BenQ was exceptionally fast with PSX disc (Lybcrypt).
During SecuROM v2 ripping, the drive was faster than the 832S and DD0405, but
when it comes to SafeDisc v2 disc, the drive was very slow. It completed the
ripping
process in 44:35 min. However, all discs were read successfully, regardless
of the ripping speed.
- Writing Tests
The DW1600A DL recorder supports the DAO-RAW writing mode. For checking
the drive's EFM correction status, we used 5 different game titles with different
SafeDisc 2 versions having the latest software patches installed. After making
the images of the various titles onto the hard disk, we burned them (maximum
speed) with Alcohol 120% v1.9.2.1705. Two different discs were created for
each title; one with the "Bypass EFM error" enabled and one more
with the function disabled.
- Fifa 2004 - Safe Disc v3.1x
- The Sims Superstar - Safe Disc v2.9x
- The Sims Unleashed - Safe Disc v2.8x
- Serious Sam Second Encounter - Safe Disc v2.51.021
- Max Payne - Safe Disc v2.51.020
The table below shows the results of the attempted backups and whether they
worked (game installed / played normally), or not.
Drive
|
Fifa 2004
SD v3.1x
|
Sims Superstar
SD v2.9x
|
Sims Unleashed
SD v2.8x
|
Serious Sam-Second Encounter
SD v2.50.051
|
Max Payne
SD v2.51.020
|
EFM OFF
|
EFM ON
|
EFM OFF
|
EFM ON
|
EFM OFF
|
EFM ON
|
EFM OFF
|
EFM ON
|
EFM OFF
|
EFM ON
|
Toshiba
SD-M1502
|
No |
No |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Creative CD5233E
|
BenQ DW1600A
DL
|
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
The above table indicates that DW1600A DL is not a suitable drive for copying
SafeDisc protected discs. Only some versions of Safedisc protection could be
backed up, and the backups played only when the DW1600A was used as the reader.
6. DAE Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 6
DAE
Tests
- Pressed and CDR AudioCD results
The DW1600A supports up to 40X CAV DAE speed. The following results
were reported when using Exact Audio Copy.
When
a pressed CD was used, the DW1600A was slightly faster than the DD0405 and
slower than the 832S, but when CD-R media was used, BenQ's drive was the slowest
among the three drives.
Of course, firmware updates can improve this performance.
As EAC reports,
the drive cannot cache DAE, supports accurate stream and cannot report C2
error information.
- Advanced DAE Quality
The DW1600A achieved a perfect quality score of 100 in Nero's
CD Speed Advanced DAE test. The drive can read Leadin data, CD Text and Subchannel
data, but cannot read Leadout data. The reported average speed was 29.16X.
- Ripping 90mins AudioCDs
The drive can read/rip flawlessly 90min Audio CDs at an average
speed of 31.94X (42.24X max speed).
- Ripping 99mins AudioCDs
The drive can also read/rip 99min Audio CDs with no problem.
The reported speed in this case was 33.23X (44.56X max speed).
7. Protected AudioCD Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 7
Protected AudioCDs
For the test procedure we used three audio discs with different
audio copy protections. The ripping process on all protected Audio
discs was carried out with Exact Audio Copy v0.9beta5.
The tested protected Audio discs were:
- Sony's Key2Audio from "Celine Dion - New Day Has Come"
- Cactus Data Shield 200 from "Natalie Imbruglia - White Lilies
Island"
The Cactus Data Shield 200, contains artificial errors that are not easily
bypassed by the reader, while the Key2Audio contains a second session,
causing problems for readers when trying to read the Table Of Contents (TOC).
The tested tasks are:
- Recognition of the inserted disc (Yes/No).
- Ripping all wavs (with EAC's Burst Mode) to the hard disk with copy&compare
function.
- Listening to the produced wavs for any click/skips.
The DW1600A DL recognized up to the 12th Audio track of CDS200 disc,
and with the "Retrieve Native TOC" option removed
the 13th Data track.
The test results are shown in the following table:
|
Key2Audio
|
CDS200
|
BenQ DW1600A DL
|
Ripping process completed, EAC reports
no problems, Read&Test CRC comparison successful for all tracks
|
Ripping process completed, EAC reports
no problems, Read&Test CRC comparison successful for all tracks
|
The BenQ DW1600A DL could rip both Key2Audio/CDS200
protected audio discs. Both discs were recognized and their contents were
ripped at maximum speed. The drive rips 100% accurately, and EAC did
not report timing problems and at the same time, Read&Test CRC check
comparison was the same for all tracks.
- Cactus Data Shield 200.0.4 - 3.0 build 16a (Aiko Katsukino - The Love
Letter)
This
is a "special" CDS200 build, since it doesn't contain any artificial
errors during the ripping process. Most problems occur when trying to write
the ripped wav files, since the produced CD-R disc contains C2 and CU errors!
This "problem" is rumored to be connected with specific chipset weaknesses.
We ripped the disc contents with EAC and burned the wav file produced from
the Cactus Data Shield 200.0.4 - 3.0 build 16a disc with the latest Nero version
as AudioCD+CD-Text. The burned
media was checked for C1/C2 errors and for BETA/Jitter errors with PlexTools
software using Plextor
PX-712SA (firmware v1.03) and LiteOn LDW-811S (firmware vHS0Q).
|
CDS 200.0.4 - 3.0 build
16a
|
BenQ DW1600A DL
|
Reading performed without any errors,
writing produces C2 spikes.
|
- C1C2 Error rate from PleXWriter PX-712SA (8X CLV reading speed)
- C1C2 Error Rate from LiteON LDW-811S (32X CAV reading speed)
- C1C2 Error Rate from BenQ DW1600A DL (32X CAV reading speed)
- BETA/Jitter Error rate from PleXWriter PX-712SA
The C1/C2 error graphs indicate that the drive didn't manage to produce a
100% error free disc.
Lets try to extract all wav files with the Plextor PX-712A and PlexTools
DAE Error Correction 5th Level enabled:
No errors were reported after extracting all files, despite
the high spike (C2) PlexTools reported around 40minutes. The drive's error
correction
mechanism corrected the errors.
8. CD Recording Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 8
CD
Recording Tests
- CD-R Format
The drive supports 8X, 12X, 16X (CLV), 32X, 40X (P-CAV) writing speeds.
According to Nero CDSpeed, the drive reached the maximum 40X
speed. The test started at 17.73X and finished at 40.53X having an average
speed of 30.32X. Click on the image below to see the whole graph.
- CD-R Recording Times
For the burning tests, we created an 80min data compilation through
Nero Burning Rom, recorded the data on a 700MB disc. DW1600A finished
the task in 3:30 minutes, when writing at 40X, 14 seconds
slower than the other two drives.
The writing performance varies according to the inserted media,
as our tests
showed. Below is a chart listing the corresponding recording times for various
media.
The best performance came with Taiyo Yuden 80min 52X media
with 207secs (3:27mins). The highest recording time was with Mam
80min 52X media at 348secs (5:48mins) as the drive could not write at the maximum
speed
with this media and only 16X writing speed was achieved.
- Other features
The DW1600A supports overburning, writing up to 99min. and can
read/write CD-Text.
- CD-RW Format
The DW1600A supports 16X CLV, 24X Z-CLV rewriting speeds
with Ultra Speed Rewritable Media
(US-RW). The drive also writes at 4X CLV with NS CD-RW
and 10X CLV with HS-RW discs.
Below you can see the Nero CD-DVD Speed writing
simulation test with blank 24x US-RW media from Mitsubishi Chemicals. We
also used Nero Burning Rom in order to burn a data disc
with 24x US-RW media from MC. The data compilation we burned had a size
of 651 MB and the duration of the recording process was 3:49 minutes.
It should be noted that when trying to write at 24X with firmware
version B5B9, the drive supported 24X P-CAV but a different curve was produced.
WOPC must have been added for CD-RW media in the B5C9 firmware. Also, using
B5B9 firmware version, it was not possible to write at 16X, getting an error
message from Nero software. Of course, this problem was solved with
the new firmware version B5C9. You can check the graph produced from Nero CD-DVD
Speed and the error message when trying to burn at 16X below:
- CD-RW Mount Rainier Tests
The BenQ DW1600A DL does not support the Mount Rainier
format.
9. Writing Quality Tests - 3T Jitter Tests
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 9
Writing Quality Tests - 3T Jitter Tests
In the following page we present the 3T Pit & Land Jitter graphs
when using
various media burned at 40X CAV writing speed.
- 3T Pit results
The drive's performance can be characterized as average
with most media used. The highest 3T Pit jitter reached was 42nsec with TraxData
52x media, which is way above
the
Red
Book limit of 35nsec and was the worst performer among the media used. It should
be noted that the DW1600A
can
write
TraxData 52X media at 16X maximum speed, an issue that should be sorted out
with a new firmware update from BenQ. The best results came with BenQ CD-R
media which was the only media that managed to stay below the 35nsec limit.
- 3T Land results
The average 3T Land results were similar to those with Pit jitter.
The maximum 3T Land Jitter reached 42nsec and again, TraxData 52X CD-R media
produced
the
worst
results, while Verbatim and to some extent BenQ (it had high Jitter towards the
end) CD-R media produced the best.
In the following page we check the C1 and C2 error rates of the
same discs, to come up with more specific conclusions.
10. Writing Quality Tests - C1 / C2 Error Measurements
BenQ DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 10
Writing Quality Tests - C1 / C2 Error Measurements
We measured the C1 / C2 error rate of the recorded discs we burned at the
various supported writing speeds. The software used was PleXTools Professional
v2.13, and particularly the built-in Q-Check utility. The reader was the Plextor
PX-712A (firmware v1.02). All media was burned with B5C9 firmware.
BenQ 80min 52X @ 40X
Intenso 80min 52X @ 40X
Mam SGUltra Golden Dye 80min 52X @ 16X
SKC 80min 52X @ 40X
TraxData 80min 52X @ 40X
TY 80min 48X @ 40X
Verbatim Super Azo 80min 52X @ 40X
- Summary
The DW1600A produced good quality burns with some
exceptions. C2 errors were reported with BenQ, Intenso,
Traxdata and Verbatim media, but always at low levels. Of course, C2 errors
can be corrected but a good burn shouldn't produce them in the first place.
- Appendix
Media Label
|
ID Code
|
Manufacturer Name
|
Lead Out TIme
|
Verbatim 80min 52X
|
97m34s23f
|
Verbatim
|
79m59s73f
|
Intenso 80min 52X
|
97m32s19f
|
Prodisc
|
79m59s71f
|
SKC 80min 52X
|
97m26s26f
|
SKC Co., Ltd.
|
79m59s73f
|
Mam SGUltra 80min 52X
|
97m27s58f
|
Mitsui Chemicals
|
79m59s74f
|
BenQ 80min 48X
|
97m22s67f
|
Daxon Technology
|
79m59s74f
|
TY 80min 48X
|
97m24s 1f
|
Taiyo Yuden
|
79m59s72f
|
TraxData 80min 52X
|
97m15s17f
|
Ritek
|
79m59s70f
|
11. DVD Recording Tests - Page 1
BenQ DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 11
DVD Recording Tests - Page 1
- Writing Performance
The BenQ DW1600A supports only DVD+R/RW and DVD+R DL writing.
However, BenQ will provide support for DVD-R/RW writing with the DW1600A
in a firmware update in the future.
The maximum supported speed for DVD+R is 16X (6X~16X
P-CAV), 4X CLV for DVD+RW and 2.4X for
DVD+R DL media. Nero Burning Rom reported speeds are shown below. Notice
that the
drive burns CLV at 2.4X and 4X writing speeds for DVD+R
formats .
A new feature that is supported by the DW1600A DL recorder
is over-speed
burning. As there aren't many 16X DVD+R media available
on the market, BenQ claims that users can still experience 16X and 12X
writing
speed with 8X DVD+R media. 10 brands of DVD+R media were tested, and according
to BenQ, the over-speed burning media support list is shown in the table
below (based on f/w B5C9, a newer version will support more 8X DVD+R media
in over-speed burning):
By using Nero CD-DVD Speed's "create disc" function,
we are able to see the 8X , 12X and 16X recording technology being used by
the DW1600A DL recorder:
The drive completed successful DVD writing at 8X in 8:52min.
It started writing at 5.26X, reached a maximum writing speed of 8.05X and
reported an average speed of 7.51X.
The drive completed successful DVD writing at 12X in 6:53min.
Starting at 6.07X, it reached a maximum writing speed of 12.05X
and
reported an average speed of 10.38X.
- 16X DVD+R Single Layer writing
The drive completed successful DVD writing at 16X in 6:07min.
It started to writing at 6.08X, reached a maximum writing speed of 16.01X
and reported an average speed of 11.44X.
12. DVD Recording Tests - Page 2
BenQ DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 12
DVD Recording Tests - Page
2
- Burning Tests
We burned 4315MB of data on various DVD+R, DVD+RW media. (We remind you that
-R/-RW media is not supported with this drive yet). We used the maximum
allowed
writing speed for each disc.
Below are all the results with the various media types used.
- 4X Speed DVD recording times (sec)
At 4X, there were no big surprises with the writing speed,
with the
fastest burning time being 878sec, with Taiyo Yuden 4X media.
- 8X Speed DVD recording times (sec)
At 8X speed, the fastest burning time came with CMC Magnetics
8X media, at 503sec.
- 12X Speed DVD recording times (sec)
When we tried to burn at 8X speed, we observed that the drive
supports up to 12X for 3A and Philips 8X media (over-speed burning). We used
the maximum speed allowed for these discs, along with normal 12X media. The
best results
came
with Maxell
12X media (387sec).
BenQ claims that more 8X media will be recorded at 12X
in the future as new firmware revisions will be released to support a wider
range of over-speed burning compatible media. The following figure indicates
the supported writing speeds for Philips 8X media under Nero.
- 16X Speed DVD recording times (sec)
At 16X, Philips media performed better than Plextor/TY 16X media,
achieving 358sec burning time (5:58min).
It is very interesting to investigate the writing quality for
16X. Comments on the writing quality test results can be seen later on this
review.
- DVD Overburning Test
Using Nero CD-DVD Speed v3.01, we tested if the BenQ DW1600A
DL can overburn using DVD+R media. Unfortunately, the drive does not support
overburning,
when it comes to DVD+R media, giving the following error with all inserted
media.
13. KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 1
BenQ DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 13
KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 1
In the following screenshots, you can see the PI/PIF scans
for DVD+R/RW media we burned with the BenQ DW1600A DL. The software we
used
for all measurements is KProbe v2.1.0, and the reader is the LiteOn LDW-811S
with "HS0Q
patched" firmware, being able to read DVD±R/RW media up to 8X
CAV. All scans have been performed at 8X with PI/PIF Sum8. Note that LiteOn
drives cannot report PO but PIF errors, despite what KProbe reports. In addition,
all discs have been scanned with PX-712A v1.01 using PlexTools v2.14 for
comparison levels.
Comparing the KProbe/PlexTools scans, we can see major differences
in the reported PI/PIF error rates. The main explanation is that we have
two different
readers, with different pickup/chipset combinations, scanning at different
reading speeds (8X CAV for KProbe, 2X CLV for PlexTools). It's interesting
to see the disc scanned at low & high speed, since when the error rate
increases at a specific region on the disc, it should appear in both scans...else
it would be,
perhaps, a reading glitch of the tested reader.
Note: PI/PIF errors only give us a quick look
at the error rate for the burned media. Those scans should be taken not as
the absolute
criteria of the burning quality but as an indication level.
3A 4X DVD+R @ 4X
CMC Magnetics 4X DVD+R @ 4X
MCC 4X DVD+R @ 4X
MMORE 4X DVD+R @ 4X
ProMedia 4X DVD+R @ 4X
TraxData 4X DVD+R @ 4X
Taiyo Yuden 4x DVD+R @ 4X
- Summary
The drive produces great burns at 4X speed. The worst results
came with 3A 4X DVD+R discs, but these results could still be described
as error free. After all, good quality burns were expected at this speed, as
higher
writing speeds might produce errors, but at low speed there really isn't any
excuse for errors.
- Appendix
Disc Label
|
Disc Information
|
Max Allowed Writing Speed
|
Total Recording Time (mins)
|
3A 4X |
POMSC001 002 |
4X |
14:56 |
TY 4X |
YUDEN000 T01 |
4X |
14:38 |
MMORE 4X |
MBIPG101 R03 |
4X |
14:45 |
MCC 4X |
MCC 002 |
4X |
14:40 |
CMC 4X |
CMC MAG F01 |
4X |
14:42 |
TraxData 4X |
RICOH HJPN R01 |
4X |
14:50 |
ProMedia |
AML 001 |
4X |
14:43 |
14. KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 2
BenQ DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 14
KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 2
In the following screenshots you can see the PI/PIF scans
for the DVD+R/RW media we burned with the BenQ DW1600A DL. The software
we used for all measurements is KProbe v2.1.0, and the reader is
the LiteOn LDW-811S with "HS0Q patched" firmware, being able
to read DVD±R/RW media up to 8X CAV. All scans have been performed
at 8X with PI/PIF Sum8. Note that LiteOn drives cannot report PO but
PIF errors, despite what KProbe reports. In addition, all discs have
been scanned with PX-712A v1.01 using PlexTools v2.14 for comparison
levels.
Comparing the KProbe/PlexTools scans we can see major differences
in the reported PI/PIF error rates. The main explanation is that we have
two different readers, with different pickup/chipset combinations, scanning
at different reading speeds (8X CAV for KProbe, 2X CLV for PlexTools).
It's interesting to see the disc scanned at low & high speed, since
when error rate increases at a specific disc area, it should appear in
both scans...else it would be, perhaps, a reading glitch of the tested
reader.
Note: PI/PIF errors only give us a quick
look at the error rate of the burned media. Those scans should be taken
not as the absolute criteria of the burning quality but as an indication
level.
CMC Magnetics 8X DVD+R @ 8X
Intenso 8X DVD+R @ 8X
TraxData 8X DVD+R @ 8X
- Summary
Again, very good results from the DW1600A. Only a small scale PI problem
is reported with TraxData 8X media, when KProbe is used. However, PlexTools
2.14 reported better quality than KProbe.
- Appendix
Disc Label
|
Disc Information
|
Max Allowed Writing Speed
|
Total Recording Time
(mins)
|
TraxData 8X
|
RITEK R03
|
8X
|
8:32
|
Intenso 8X
|
PRODISC R03
|
8X
|
8:27
|
CMC 8X
|
CMC MAG E01
|
8X
|
8:23
|
15. KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 3
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 15
KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 3
In the following screenshots you can see the PI/PIF scans
for the DVD+R/RW media we burned with the BenQ DW1600A DL. The software
we used for all measurements is KProbe v2.1.0, and the reader is
the LiteOn LDW-811S with "HS0Q patched" firmware, being able
to read DVD±R/RW media up to 8X CAV. All scans have been performed
at 8X with PI/PIF Sum8. Note that LiteOn drives cannot report PO but
PIF errors, despite what KProbe reports. In addition, all discs have
been scanned with PX-712A v1.01 using PlexTools v2.14 for comparison
levels.
Comparing the KProbe/PlexTools scans we can see major
differences in the reported PI/PIF error rates. The main explanation
is that we have two different readers, with different pickup/chipset
combinations, scanning at different reading speeds (8X CAV for KProbe,
2X CLV for PlexTools). It's interesting to see the disc scanned at low & high
speed, since when error rate increases at a specific disc area, it should
appear in both scans...else it would be, perhaps, a reading glitch of
the tested reader.
Note: PI/PIF errors only give us a quick
look at the error rate of the burned media. Those scans should be taken
not as the absolute criteria of the burning quality but as an indication
level.
3A 8X DVD+R @ 12X
Maxell 8X DVD+R @ 12X
Philips 8X DVD+R @ 12X
LiteON 8X DVD+R @ 12X
- Summary
Some of the media that was recorded at 12X was 8X media. The DW1600A
managed to make successful writings at 12X by using over-speed burning technology.
As there isn't a lot of variety in 12X media on the market, this is a clever
approach by BenQ. Good quality burns were reported by both
KProbe
and
PlexTools. Minor quality problems reported with 3A 8X media (writing
speed 12X) are not worthy of notice. It should be noted that with LiteOn
8X @
12X media, KProbe scan reported a better quality burn than the Plextools
scan.
- Appendix
Disc Label
|
Disc Information
|
Max Allowed Writing Speed
|
Total Recording Time
(mins)
|
3A 8X
|
Plasmon1 C01
|
12X
|
6:33
|
Philips 8X
|
PHILIPS C08
|
12X
|
6:28
|
LiteON 8X |
RICOHJPN R02 |
12X |
6:28 |
Maxell 8X |
MAXELL 002 |
12X |
6:27 |
16. KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 4
BenQ DW1600A DL Recorder - Page 16
KProbe/PlexTools Scans - Page 4
In the following screenshots you can see the PI/PIF scans
for the DVD+R/RW media we burned with the BenQ DW1600A DL. The software
we used for all measurements is KProbe v2.1.0, and the reader is
the LiteOn LDW-811S with "HS0Q patched" firmware, being able
to read DVD±R/RW media up to 8X CAV. All scans have been performed
at 8X with PI/PIF Sum8. Note that LiteOn drives cannot report PO but
PIF errors, despite what KProbe reports. In addition, all discs have
been scanned with PX-712A v1.01 using PlexTools v2.14 for comparison
levels.
Comparing the KProbe/PlexTools scans we can see major differences
in the reported PI/PIF error rates. The main explanation is that we have
two different readers, with different pickup/chipset combinations, scanning
at different reading speeds (8X CAV for KProbe, 2X CLV for PlexTools).
It's interesting to see the disc scanned at low & high speed, since
when error rate increases at a specific disc area, it should appear in
both scans...else it would be, perhaps, a reading glitch of the tested
reader.
Note: PI/PIF errors only give us a quick
look at the error rate of the burned media. Those scans should be taken
not as the absolute criteria of the burning quality but as an indication
level.
Philips 16X DVD+R @ 16X
Plextor 8X DVD+R @ 16X (DVD-ROM Format)
Plextor 8X DVD+R @ 16X (DVD+R Format)
- Summary
Plextor 8X media was recorded at 16X. The writing quality at this speed
was not expected to be as good as at lower speeds. Plextor 8X media produced
a "read error" near the end of the reading process. The media
was supposed to be written at 8X but instead was written at 16X. So,
this error is reasonable.
It should also be noted that the error occurred with the DVD+R format, while
the disc with DVD-ROM format reported no read errors. Philips 16X media produced
better results than Plextor 16X media, but results from
both
media
were more
than
acceptable.
Very good
performance
from the BenQ
DW1600A DL.
- Appendix
Disc Label
|
Disc Information
|
Max Allowed Writing Speed
|
Total Recording Time
(mins)
|
Philips 16X |
PHILIPS C16 |
16X |
5:58 |
Plextor 16X |
YUDEN000 T02 |
16X |
6:06 |
Plextor 16X (DVD-ROM Booktype
|
YUDEN000 T02 |
16X |
6:08 |
17. DVD+R DL - Page 1
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 17
DVD+R DL - Page 1
- DVD+R DL BookType Setting
The DW1600A
is capable of writing Double Layer discs, nearly doubling the capacity that
can be stored on one disc. BenQ was one of the first companies
to add DL support in DVD+R recorders. For our tests we used the media sent
by LiteON for our tests, based on Mitsubishi Chemicals with the following
information, as reported from DVDInfoPro
software:
BenQ Book Type Management v.8.2 program ensures media
backward compatibility with older DVD players. This program allows us to
freely choose a DVD+RW, DVD+R or DVD+R DL disc to be written as DVD-ROM book
type,
the most recognized disc format for DVD players.
After pressing the "Set to DVD-ROM Type" a warning
message informed us that the BookType setting can be changed before burning:
Unfortunately, we cannot change the BookType setting for already
burned media with the BenQ DW1600A DL. As BenQ said, the BookType setting
highly improves the compatibility with DVD players. Due to the limited amount
of DVD+R
DL media, we didn't have the chance for now, to test how the Booktype
setting affects compatibility.
There is also an easier way to change the Booktype setting,
within Nero 6.0 right before the writing process begins.
- Writing Tests
We burned a DVD+R DL disc with DVD-Video content. The
source disc was "Gladiator Movie - Special
Edition" disc1 with a total size of 6.86GB. First we transferred the
movie to the hard disc with DVD Decrypter as ISO format (single file).
Afterwards, we used
CopyToDVD v3.0.0.16. The friendly wizard prompts us to choose from among
the main tasks:
For our test, we used the "Movie & Pictures" option,
and then the "Write DVD Video".
The software prompts us to select Video_TS/ISO image folder.
We chose the "GLADIATOR.ISO" image and we selected the BenQ DW1600A
DL burner.
After pressing "OK", the burning procedure started,
without any unexpected delays (such as 50secs delay with the LiteON 832S).
It should be noted that the Booktype setting was not changed, to test if
it will
be
changed automatically by the software:
The writing process was finished after 40:16 minutes.
The average speed was 2.24X as reported from CopyToDVD software. The recorded
disc was in DVD-ROM format, with the booktype setting having been changed
automatically by the software.
For comparison reasons, we post some burning results from
other DL writers, which all burned the same content ("Gladiator Movie
- Special Edition" disc1), using CopyToDVD software:
Drive
|
Time (mins)
|
BenQ DW1600A DL |
40:16 |
BenQ DW830A
|
39:14
|
NEC 2510A
|
37:17
|
LiteON SOHW-832S DVD+R DL BookType
|
38:33
|
LiteON SOHW-832S DVD-ROM BookType
|
38:36
|
SONY DRU-700A
|
|
The best recording performance comes from the NEC 2510A, while
the BenQ DW1600A DL came last with 40:16mins.
18. DVD+R DL - Page 2
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 18
- Writing Quality
In order to test the BenQ DW1600A DVD+R DL writing quality, we used not
our usual readers (LiteOn LDW-811S/Plextor PX-712A) but the LiteOn SOHD-167T
firmware 9S13, LiteOn XJ-HD165H firmware CH11, and LiteOn LTD-163 firmware
GH5S. Similar
results were reported from all three drives.
Using KProbe v2.1.0, we got a very good scan, indicating very good quality
performance from the drive with the DL media recorded. Notice that the disc
is not read at 3~8 CAV, but at 2.5X~5X CAV (DVD+R DL media).
Using the Plextor PX-712A and PlexTools, we were able to scan
the DVD+R DL media with DVD-ROM booktype:
The reported PI error rate did not reach the 280 limit and
no PO failures were reported, giving again an image of a very good quality
burned disc.
We also tried using Nero CD-DVD Speed and its "Disc Quality"
utility to ensure that the reported results are correct. Using two different
LiteON drives we got the following results:
LiteOn LTD-163 firmware
GH5S
LiteOn XJ-HD165H firmware CH11
Both drives gave worse scans than Kprobe and Plextools reported,
and they both gave a quality score of 76. The disc was read without any
problems for both layers.
- Compatibility Matrix
For our compatibility tests, we used the burned DVD+R DL discs with DVD-Video
content ("Gladiator Movie - Special Edition" Disc1) and PowerDVD
v5.0. The disc was also checked with several stand-alone DVD players.
We moved front and back around the layer change to ensure that the movie
can be playback without any glitches or skips. The results are shown below:
Device
|
Firmware
|
DVD-ROM Booktype
|
LiteOn SOHW-812S
|
vUSOJ
|
Playback is perfect
|
LiteOn LDW-811S
|
vHS0Q
|
Disc size recognized under CDSpeed
but not disc contents under Windows
|
LiteOn SOHC-5232K
|
vNK07
|
Playback is perfect
|
Panasonic LDF-511
|
vA112
|
Playback is perfect
|
Philips DVDR824P
|
vP1.2
|
Not recognized
|
Pioneer DCR-111
|
v1.26
|
Playback is perfect
|
Pioneer A06
|
v1.07
|
Playback is perfect
|
BenQ DW822A
|
vB3HC
|
Not recognized
|
Samsung SH-W08A
|
v1S30
|
Not recognized
|
Optorite DD405
|
v1.50E
|
Playback is perfect
|
Optorite DD203
|
v2.25
|
Playback is perfect
|
TEAC DV-516E
|
v2.01
|
Not recognized
|
BTC BDV-316B
|
v0.47
|
Playback is perfect
|
Plextor PX-712A
|
v1.01
|
Playback is perfect
|
Plextor PX-712SA
|
v1.02
|
Playback is perfect
|
NEC 2510A
|
v2.15
|
Playback is perfect
|
NEC 2500A
|
v1.07
|
Playback is perfect
|
LiteOn LTD-163D
|
vGH5S
|
Playback is perfect
|
LiteOn LTD-165H
|
vCH11
|
Playback is perfect
|
Toshiba SD-1502 |
v1012 |
Playback
is perfect |
Toshiba SD-1612 |
v1004 |
Playback
is perfect |
LG DV8600 |
- |
Playback
is perfect |
Sony DVP - NS330 |
- |
Playback
is perfect |
Sony DVP - NS730P |
- |
Playback
is perfect |
Sony DVP - PQ2 |
- |
Playback
is perfect |
Waitec DVD-X4 |
- |
Disc recognized, playback is jerky |
Waitec Vision-HR |
- |
Disc recognized, playback is jerky |
Sony DVP - NS730P |
- |
Playback is perfect |
19. DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 1
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 19
DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 1
For checking exactly what the DW1600A DL reports, we used different media,
burned by other recorders. These four media have been measured with the
well known AudioDev SA300 DVD CATS system at 1X.
We used Nero CD/DVD Speed and its disc quality utility. We compared
those measurements at various reading speeds:
Please note that the posted results are only valid for the specific tested BenQ
DW1600A DL drive. Using other DW1600A DL drives can produce totally different
results. Be aware!
#1st Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 8X Reading speed
#1st Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 6X Reading
speed
#1st Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 4X Reading
speed
The PIF error rate trend line follows that of the SA300,
however at lower levels. Similar results were reported
for all speed conditions.
At the end of the disc, the PI/PIF error rate increases. The SA300 system
also
measured similar performance. Nero CD/DVD Speed gave this disc a quality score
of 0.
20. DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 2
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 20
DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 2
For checking exactly what the DW1600A DL reports, we used different media,
burned with other recorders. These four media have been measured with the
well known AudioDev SA300 DVD CATS system at 1X.
We used Nero CD/DVD Speed and its disc quality utility. We compared those
measurements at various reading speeds:
Please note that the posted results are only valid for the specific tested BenQ
DW1600A DL drive. Using other DW1600A DL drives can produce totally different
results. Be aware!
#2nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 8X Reading speed
#2nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 6X Reading speed
#2nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 4X Reading speed
Totally different results were reported from CD/DVD Speed Disc
Quality utility and from SA300 series. The use of the DW1600A DL as a reader
is not recommended at this point, because it reports the disc to be in perfect
shape, giving very good results and low error level rates.
21. DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 3
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 21
DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 3
For checking exactly what the DW1600A DL reports, we used different media,
burned with other recorders. These four media have been measured with the
well known AudioDev SA300 DVD CATS system at 1X.
We used Nero CD/DVD Speed and its disc quality utility. We compared those
measurements at various reading speeds:
Please note that the posted results are only valid for the specific tested BenQ
DW1600A DL drive. Using other DW1600A DL drives can produce totally different
results. Be aware!
#3nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 8X Reading speed
#3nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 6X Reading speed
#3nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 4X Reading speed
When the drive was reading at the extremes (inner and
outer regions) of the discs, it reports lower error level rates than the
SA300 series
did.
However, when reading in the middle region of the discs, the error level rates
were reported as they should. But again, the DW1600A is not recommended as
a reader, as it was unable to report error levels in certain areas of the disc.
22. DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 4
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 22
DW1600A DL vs. SA300 - Page 4
For checking exactly what the DW1600A DL reports, we used different media,
burned with other recorders. These four media have been measured with the
well known AudioDev SA300 DVD CATS system at 1X.
We used Nero CD/DVD Speed and its disc quality utility. We compared those
measurements at various reading speeds:
Please note that the posted results are only valid for the specific tested BenQ
DW1600A DL drive. Using other DW1600A DL drives can produce totally different
results. Be aware!
#4nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 8X Reading speed
#4nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 6X Reading speed
#4nd Test Disc - PISum8/PIF Comparison - 4X Reading speed
The tested disc was a Double Layer disc. The reported error level
rates are again different from the actual errors reported by the SA300 series,
and much higher when the reader was starting to read the second layer. However,
they better approach the actual errors. Again, the DW1600A
DL is not recommended as a reader for this disc.
23. Conclusion
BenQ
DW1600A DL Recorder -
Page 23
Conclusion
The
DW1600A DL is the first recorder that introduces 16X DVD recording, taking
the recording
capabilities to their limits. Over-speed
burning technology is something that end users will enjoy, as media can be
recorded at a higher speed than the media's supported writing speed. Considering
the cost of 16X DVD+R discs, and the availability of these discs, it is a
clever approach by BenQ. Burning quality is a headache at these speeds, but
the High-Speed Signal Algorithm shows its teeth, producing good quality burns
at 16X. Overburning is not supported with DVD+R media, along with
reading of DVD-RAM
media.
When it comes to ripping capabilities, the DW1600A's performance
is not as good as other drives on sale. However, ripping speed
might be increased with future firmware releases. And end users should remember
that
it still
is a fast drive for ripping.
CD error correction
tests showed that the DW1600A is one of the best in this category. No major
problems were reported with the Abex series test discs. In DVD error correction
tests,
again with Abex series test discs, the drive gave
no errors at all when discs with artificial black
dots, scratches and defective areas were used. An excellent performance from
BenQ's drive.
Copy protection discs is one of the weak points of this drive.
Although reading tests with these types of discs were completed successfully,
reading process of SafeDisc protected discs took a long time to complete.
The DW1600A DL is not a suitable drive for copying
SafeDisc protected discs. Only some versions of Safedisc protection could be
overcome, and only when the DW1600A was used as a reader. On the other hand,
audio protected discs were no problem for the DW1600A, and perfect copies
were created
as if there was no protection at all.
The BenQ DW1600A DL supports up to 40X CD-R writing speed, which
is not the fastest speed available, but still fast enough. Overburning is
supported
(up to 99min). When writing CD-RW media at 16X with various media, the drive
kept on failing at 81%. We were happy to see that this problem was resolved
with a simple firmware update. When the new firmware was installed, 16X CD-RW
burning was no problem for this drive.
Writing quality of CD-R/RW discs was
rather good, with low jitter values and low C1/C2 error rates. However,
Traxdata 52X media could only be recorded at 16X, an issue that should be
sorted
in the next firmware release.
As a last word we list the positive/negative points of the
drive.
- The Good
- The Bad
- Does not support DVD-R/RW media (will be sorted in a future firmware release)
- Only 2MB buffer size
- Does not support overburning with DVD+R/RW media
- Cannot backup copy protected games with most versions of SafeDisc
protection
- Doesn't support reading of DVD-RAM media
- Doesn't support C2 error information
- Like To be fixed
- Burning quality at 16X with DVD+R media
- C2 errors with certain media at 40X