BenQ DW830A DL recorder
5. Booktype compatibility
Review Pages
BenQ DW830A DL Recorder - page 5
- BookType Setting
The BenQ DW830A supports Booktype change with the BookType Management v8.2, that will be included at the retail package.:
After pressing the "Set to DVD-ROM Type" a warning message informed us that the BookType setting can be changed before burning:
Lets now see how the BookType changed:
Unfortunately, we cannot change the BookType setting of already burned media with BenQ DW830A. As BenQ said, the BookType setting highly improves the compatibility with DVD players. Due to limited amount of DVD+R DL media, we haven't got the chance, for now, testing how the Booktype setting affects compatibility..
- Compatibility matrix
For our compatibility tests, we used the #1st burned DVD-Video test disc (DVD+R DL BookType - Gladiator movie) and PowerDVD v5.0. We moved forward and backwards around layer change addresses to ensure that movie can be playbacked without any glitches or skips. The results are shown below:
Drive
|
Type
|
Firmware
|
Comments
|
LiteOn SOHW-812S
|
DVD Writer
|
vUSOJ
|
Reads the disc without any problems
|
LiteOn LDW-811S
|
vHS0K
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
|
LiteOn SOHC-5232K
|
Combo
|
vNK07
|
Recognizes the disc as DVD+R DL, movie
doesn't start with PowerDVD, can playback some Vob files, when laser
reaches Layer 1 drive makes noises and denies continuing
|
Pioneer DCR-111
|
v1.26
|
Recognizes disc as DVD+R DL, playback
is perfect
|
|
Panasonic LDF-511
|
DVD Writer
|
vA112
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
Pioneer A06
|
v1.07
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
|
BenQ DW800A
|
vB3D7
|
Recognizes the inserted disc, but
not the content!
|
|
LiteOn LDW-431SX
|
vMS0J
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
|
Optorite DD405
|
v1.50E
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
|
Pioneer A07
|
v1.12
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
|
Pioneer DVD-500M |
DVD-ROM
|
v1.02
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
BTC BDV-316B
|
v0.47
|
Recognizes ok, playback is good, however
drive stops responding after FF/FW
|
|
LiteOn LTD-163
|
vGH5S
|
Recognizes disc as DVD+R DL, playback
is perfect
|
|
LiteOn LTD-165H
|
vCH11
|
Recognizes disc as DVD+R DL, playback
is perfect
|
|
Pioneer DVD-116/S2
|
v1.22
|
Recognizes disc as DVD+R DL, playback
is perfect
|
|
TEAC DV-516E
|
v2.01
|
Cannot recognize inserted disc
|
It seems there are huge problems with DVD+R DL media as our short investigation showed. Most DVD Writers refused to recognize the DVD+R DL media. On the other hand, the newest LiteOn SOHW-812S didn't had any problems and read the whole disc flawlessly. It's interesting that even BenQ DW800A cannot properly recognize the DL media.
As for combos, the LiteOn SOHK-5232K did recognize the media, however it failed to read the Layer1. The situation with the DVD-ROMs is slightly better although only three (3) out of the six tested models managed to playback without any issues, two of them didn't recognize the media at all and the last one read the media with problems.
We didn't test the burned DVD+R DL media with any DVD players. BenQ advises to use the DVD+R DL DVD-ROM BookType for testing with both DVD players and DVD-ROMs.
Review Pages