Pioneer BDR-XD08UMB-S External Blu-Ray Recorder
14. PureRead 4+ - Page 1
Review Pages
2. Drive Information
3. Testing Software
4. Explain Error Correction
5. CD Reading Tests
6. CD Defect Disc Tests
7. DVD Reading Tests
8. DVD Defect Disc Tests
9. Blu-Ray Reading Tests
10. CD Writing Tests
11. DVD-R Writing Tests
12. DVD+R Writing Tests
13. Blu-Ray Writing Tests
14. PureRead 4+ - Page 1
15. PureRead 4+ - Page 2
16. Conclusion
Pioneer has included at thei XD08 series their latest CD-DA extraction mechanism, that is called "PureRead" (Source 1 and 2) and steps up to version 4+. You can read more about this technology at our related article.
A summary of Pioneer's PureRead technologies from v1 up to v4 can be summarized below:
- Pure Read: On CD ripping, when read error happens, change one read parameter from the parameter candidate (rotation speed, pickup parameters etc) and retry read
- Pure Read+: Drive remembers Pure Read settings.
- Pure Read 2+: Added new read parameter to some specific disc conditions.
- Pure Read 3+: Introduces Pure Read on real-time CD playback , Real Time Pure Read.
- Pure Read 4+: When read error happens, change 2 or more parameters and retry.
- Standard Mode (PureRead OFF): On CD ripping, when C2 error happens, interpolate sample gap and read continues.
- Master Mode: On CD ripping, when read error happens, change read parameter and retry (Pure Read). if several retry failed, interpolate sample gap and read continues.
- Perfect Mode: Same as “Master Mode” but when several retry failed, reports read error to OS and stop ripping.
In order to test PureRead 4+, first we used the ABEX TCD-714 and with the Pioneer drive and the EAC Secure function we ripped the "secure" audio contents of the Audio CD. Then by using both Abex TCD-721 and TCD-726 test discs with the Pioneer drive and ripping them with EAC BURST function we got several files that we will be compared afterwards with the DeltaWave Audio Null Comparator to check how many differences are and they will audible for end users. Lastly, we used the Nero CD-DVD Advanced DAE Tests to check how PureRead 4+ affects the overall score or not.
The Pioneer PureRead 4+ function can be disabled with the Pioneer BD Drive Utility, enable it at Perfect Mode or Master Mode (+ Real Time Pure Read).
Using the ABEX TCD-726 with Nero CD-DVD Speed gives us some first results.
ABEX TCD-726 Nero CD-DVD Speed Advanced DAE Tests Comparison |
||
C2 Accuracy |
Quality Score (%) |
|
No PureRead 4+ | 75.03% |
99.5 |
PureRead 4+ Perfect mode | unknown |
94.9 |
PureRead 4+Master Mode | 73.40% |
99.9 |
The no Pure Read 4+ and PureRead 4+ Master mode, gave us somewhat similar results.
Then we ripped the contents of the Abex TCD-726 and we compared each track with go from the Abex TCD-714R, which includes the same disc contents, but without defects. EAC after each rip give us a log that states if the track is accurate rip or not, at least according to each algorithms. We also compared all tracks with DeltaWare software that can compare WAV files and report back the match % and its own PK Meter that represents the possibility to hear hiss/clicks/distortion. The higher negative values the better, the lower (towards zero) the worst. A good value would be below 150dBFS. Also best case scenario would be to have all tracks 100% match with -∞dBFS value.
ABEX TCD-726 / 6th Track Analysis Comparison |
|||
Ripping Method |
EAC AccurateRip Log |
DeltaWave Comparison with ABEX TCD-714 |
DeltaWave PK Meter |
EAC BURST |
Accurately ripped |
Files are a bit-perfect match at 16 bits |
RMS=-∞dBFS |
EAC SECURE |
No match |
99.9997% |
RMS=-153.6dBFS |
EAC BURST + PERFECT Pioneer Mode |
Accurately ripped |
Files are a bit-perfect match at 16 bits |
RMS=-∞dBFS |
EAC BURST + MASTER Pioneer Mode |
Accurately ripped |
Files are a bit-perfect match at 16 bits |
RMS=-∞dBFS |
ABEX TCD-726 / 7th Track Analysis Comparison |
|||
Ripping Method |
EAC AccurateRip Log |
DeltaWave Comparison with ABEX TCD-714 |
DeltaWave PK Meter |
EAC BURST |
No match |
99.9861% |
RMS=-106.4dBFS |
EAC SECURE |
No match |
99.9998% |
RMS=-144.5dBFS |
EAC BURST + PERFECT Pioneer Mode |
Accurately ripped |
Files are a bit-perfect match at 16 bits |
RMS=-∞dBFS |
EAC BURST + MASTER Pioneer Mode |
Accurately ripped |
Files are a bit-perfect match at 16 bits | RMS=-∞dBFS |
ABEX TCD-726 / 9th Track Analysis Comparison |
|||
Ripping Method |
EAC AccurateRip Log |
DeltaWave Comparison with ABEX TCD-714 |
DeltaWave PK Meter |
EAC BURST |
No match |
99.9996% |
RMS=-128.6dBFS |
EAC SECURE |
No match |
99.9929% |
RMS=-112.5dBFS |
EAC BURST + PERFECT Pioneer Mode |
Accurately ripped |
Files are a bit-perfect match at 16 bits |
RMS=-∞dBFS |
EAC BURST + MASTER Pioneer Mode |
No match |
99.9996% |
RMS=-147.1dBFS |
ABEX TCD-726 / 10th Track Analysis Comparison |
|||
Ripping Method |
EAC AccurateRip Log |
DeltaWave Comparison with ABEX TCD-714 |
DeltaWave PK Meter |
EAC BURST |
No match |
99.9851% |
RMS=-108.2dBFS |
EAC SECURE |
No match |
99.7185% |
RMS=-88.2dBFS |
EAC BURST + PERFECT Pioneer Mode |
No match |
97.9334% |
RMS=-42.2dBFS |
EAC BURST + MASTER Pioneer Mode |
No match | 99.4905% | RMS=-43.9dBFS |
ABEX TCD-726 / 11th Track Analysis Comparison |
|||
Ripping Method |
EAC AccurateRip Log |
DeltaWave Comparison with ABEX TCD-714 |
DeltaWave PK Meter |
EAC BURST |
No match |
99.7339% |
RMS=-105.3dBFS |
EAC SECURE |
No match |
99.742% |
RMS=-103.0dBFS |
EAC BURST + PERFECT Pioneer Mode |
No match |
99.7195% |
RMS=-56.3dBFS |
EAC BURST + MASTER Pioneer Mode |
No match | 99.8616% | RMS=-64.9dBFS |
Depending the track, we see that the EAC Burst (No Pure-Read 4+ enabled) can work very good and returns accurate-close to the original source tracks (TCD-714) compared even to EAC Secure and Perfect/Master mode. In other internal X13 Pioneer drives, it seems that PureRead 4+ worked better and surpassed EAC burst mode.
Review Pages
2. Drive Information
3. Testing Software
4. Explain Error Correction
5. CD Reading Tests
6. CD Defect Disc Tests
7. DVD Reading Tests
8. DVD Defect Disc Tests
9. Blu-Ray Reading Tests
10. CD Writing Tests
11. DVD-R Writing Tests
12. DVD+R Writing Tests
13. Blu-Ray Writing Tests
14. PureRead 4+ - Page 1
15. PureRead 4+ - Page 2
16. Conclusion