Plextor PX-712A
16. GigaRec Tests - Page 2
Review Pages
2. Data CD/DVD Reading Tests
3. CD Error Correction Tests
4. DVD Error Correction Tests
5. Protected Disc Tests
6. DAE Tests
7. CD Recording Tests
8. CD Writing Quality - Jitter Tests
9. CD Writing Quality - C1/C2 Error Measurements
10. Kprobe PI/PO Quality Tests for DVD+R/RW
11. DVD Recording Tests
12. VariREC Tests for CD Format
13. Kprobe PI/PO Quality Tests for DVD-R/RW
14. VariREC Tests for DVD Format
15. GigaRec Tests - Page 1
16. GigaRec Tests - Page 2
17. Q-Check Tests
18. PleXTools vs. SA300 - Page 1
19. PleXTools vs. SA300 - Page 2
20. PleXTools vs. SA300 - Page 3
21. SilentMode / SecuRec
22. BookType Setting Tests
23. Conclusion
Plextor PX-712A Dual DVD±RW recorder - Page 16
GigaRec - Page 2
- Playback Tests
In order to test the GigaRec function we used three CD players and the results are presented in the following table:
#1st Test Disc Batch (SKC 80min 48X)
GigaRec Rates |
|||||
Players |
0.6X |
0.7X |
0.8X |
1.2X |
1.3X |
JVC LCX-257 |
TOC recognized correctly, no playback problems |
TOC recognized
correctly, high seek times when try accessing last tracks especially
at 1.3X. When playback performed sequentially at last tracks no problems
occured.
|
|||
JVC SH-D9101 |
Below are the BETA/Jitter scans for all GigaRec tested media:
#2nd Test Disc Batch (BenQ 80min 52X)
GigaRec Rates |
|||||
Players |
0.6X |
0.7X |
0.8X |
1.2X |
1.3X |
JVC LCX-257 |
TOC recognized correctly, no playback problems |
||||
JVC KV-9101 |
#3rd Test Disc Batch (TDK 90min 40X)
GigaRec Rates |
|||||
Players |
0.6X |
0.7X |
0.8X |
1.2X |
1.3X |
JVC LCX-257 |
TOC recognized correctly, cannot playback any track (disc keeps spinning all the time focus lost) |
TOC recognized correctly, some problems with last tracks |
TOC recognized correctly, high seek times when try accessing last tracks especially at 1.3X. When playback performed sequently at last tracks no problems occured. |
||
JVC KV-9101 |
TOC recognized correctly, no playback problems |
TOC recognized correctly, no playback problems |
- Summary
If someone asked us directly, "does GigaRec work?", our answer would be definantly yes. It does work and pretty well especially with 80min CD-R media. The produced discs will playback correctly at some rates and won't at others. The used media does affect the playability as was shown from our test results.
Using the BenQ 80min 48X CD-R media, the 0.6X/0.7X/0.8X rates had no problems while the other two (1.2X/1.3X) produced minor problems. The system had problems focusing from first to the last two tracks, high seek times, but when playback was sequential no problem occured.
Using the TDK 800MB CD-R media enabled higher GigaRec rates, which however weren't that impressive since the burned media isn't playable at some parts or at all. For the two lowest GigaRec rates (0.6X, 0.7X) the only working burning speed is 4X, normally since laser needs to stay focused when producing the higher pit lenghts.
For the remaining GigaRec rates (0.8X,1.2X,1.3X), 8X burning speed is selectable, we would suggest however using again the 4X speed with the highest (1.3X) rate.
Of course as you may understand, using other CD-R media and maybe combined with VariRec can produce totally different results...;-)
- Appendix
For testing we also used Mam SGUltra 80min 48X CD-R media with the 1.3X rate. The produced disc had all the usual symptoms of the 1.3X rate but the interesting part is that the PX-712A couldn't scan the disc for Beta/Jitter error rates...
Review Pages
2. Data CD/DVD Reading Tests
3. CD Error Correction Tests
4. DVD Error Correction Tests
5. Protected Disc Tests
6. DAE Tests
7. CD Recording Tests
8. CD Writing Quality - Jitter Tests
9. CD Writing Quality - C1/C2 Error Measurements
10. Kprobe PI/PO Quality Tests for DVD+R/RW
11. DVD Recording Tests
12. VariREC Tests for CD Format
13. Kprobe PI/PO Quality Tests for DVD-R/RW
14. VariREC Tests for DVD Format
15. GigaRec Tests - Page 1
16. GigaRec Tests - Page 2
17. Q-Check Tests
18. PleXTools vs. SA300 - Page 1
19. PleXTools vs. SA300 - Page 2
20. PleXTools vs. SA300 - Page 3
21. SilentMode / SecuRec
22. BookType Setting Tests
23. Conclusion