BeQuiet Jubiläum Banner 970x90
Breaking News

Noctua introduces NA-FG1 fan grills with offset push-pin mounting Sharkoon M30 Black & M30 RGB | Elegant ATX Cases for Office and Gaming Epson Adds 4K Enhancement to Compact and Versatile 5,200 and 7,000 Lumen PowerLite L Series Laser Projectors ViewSonic's Latest 4K Presentation Displays Harness Video Conferencing AI to Put the Focus on All Meeting Participants Envision Enhances Its Range of Smart Glasses For Blind and Low-Vision Communities - Making Them More Accessible For Everyone

logo

  • Share Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
  • Home
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Essays
  • Forum
  • Legacy
  • About
    • Submit News

    • Contact Us
    • Privacy

    • Promotion
    • Advertise

    • RSS Feed
    • Site Map

Search form

EU Privacy Watchdog Accused of Delaying Probe Procedures Against Facebook

EU Privacy Watchdog Accused of Delaying Probe Procedures Against Facebook

Enterprise & IT May 25,2020 0

The Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC), Europe's main data-protection watchdog, is attacked by leading privacy advocates for taking too long to wrap up probes into Facebook Inc. and its Instagram and WhatsApp units.

Max Schrems’s group Noyb in an open letter on Monday called on European Union authorities to “take action” against the Irish Data Protection Commission, which has yet to issue any significant fines exactly two years after strict EU rules empowered the regulator to levy hefty penalties for serious privacy violations.

Within hours of the new GDPR being applicable on 25 May 2018, the European non-profit organisation noyb.eu filed three complaints against the Facebook Group (including WhatsApp and Instagram). noyb.eu says that since then, the DPC has asked the non-profit organisation not to discuss those issues in public and declared the contents of the "extremely slow procedure confidential".

Despite this alleged (and legally non-binding) confidentiality, noyb.eu on Monday published an Open Letter (PDF) that exposes how the GDPR has (not) been enforced two years after it became applicable. Even under the Kafkaesque procedure described in the letter, noyb.eu says that the Facebook Group may still have to face a fine of up to € 2.5 Billion down the road, if the DPC follows its internal investigator report.

According to the letter, the Irish DPC and the Facebook Group (including WhatsApp and Instagram) had ten secret meetings before the GDPR became applicable in 2018.

In these meetings, Facebook claims to have had “detailed direct engagement with the Commission prior to the implementation” of an apparent “consent bypass” (details below) to circumvent the GDPR’s strict consent rules. Despite the fact that Facebook relied on these meetings in its submissions and highlighted that the documents were ‘subject to consideration’ by the DPC, the authority refuses access to any records of these secret meetings, including a White Paper submitted by Facebook.

Max Schrems, chairman of noyb.eu: “It sounds a lot like those secret ‘tax rulings’ where tax authorities secretly agree with large tech companies on how to bypass the tax laws – just that they now do this with the GDPR too.”

“There were no ‘secret meetings’ held between the DPC and Facebook,” Graham Doyle, deputy commissioner at the data protection commission, said. “We regularly engage and meet with companies from all sectors as part of our regulatory enforcement and supervision functions” just as other EU data regulators do.

In the procedures that were triggered by three complaints filed by noyb.eu two years ago (within the first hours of the GDPR becoming applicable), the Facebook Group openly acknowledges that it simply switched from highly regulated “consent” to an alleged “data use contract”. This contract allegedly obliges Facebook to track, target and conduct research on its users. According to Facebook, this switch happened at the stroke of midnight when the GDPR became applicable.

Max Schrems: “It is nothing but lipstick on a pig. Since Roman times, the law prohibits ‘renaming’ something just to bypass the law. What Facebook tried to do is not smart, but laughable. The only thing that is really concerning is that the Irish DPC apparently engaged with Facebook when they were designing this scam and is now supposed to independently review it.”

In a study conducted by the Gallup Institute on the “consent bypass”, 64% of 1.000 users believe they gave consent, despite Facebook’s claims to the opposite. Depending on the question, only 1.6-2.5% thought they actually entered into a “data use contract” that includes a duty of Facebook to use their data for advertisement or research. The rest thought it is mere information, a contract without such duties or could not see any meaning in the page.

Max Schrems: “Basically none of the 1,000 users we have asked thinks they have signed such an alleged ‘data use contract’ with Facebook.”

The letter comes just days after the Irish authority said it’s edging closer to delivering its first major sanctions under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation after finalizing a draft decision in a probe concerning Twitter Inc. and completing a further procedural step in a separate probe concerning WhatsApp.

GDPR empowered regulators to levy penalties of as much as 4% of a company’s annual revenue for the most serious violations. The biggest fine to date was a 50 million-euro ($54.5 million) penalty for Google by France’s watchdog CNIL.

Tags: facebookprivacyWhatsAppinstagramGDPR
Previous Post
Samsung Develops New Security Chip For Mobile Devices
Next Post
Realme India Announces Smartwatch and TVs

Related Posts

  • Zuckerberg Says Remote Work is Here to Stay

  • Facebook to Launch New Shopping Feature Across Apps

  • EU Tech Chief Demands More From Facebook Regarding Business Practices

  • Facebook Buys GIPHY as Part of Instagram Team

  • Facebook Works With Telecoms on 2Africa Subsea Cable for Future Internet Connectivity

  • Facebook Reports Increased Number of Removals of Hate speech, Terrorism

  • Facebook Users Accept $550 Million Privacy Deal Over Facebook's “Tag Suggestions”

  • The Redesigned Facebook.com Goes Live

BeQuiet Jubiläum Banner 300x600

 

Latest News

Noctua introduces NA-FG1 fan grills with offset push-pin mounting
Cooling Systems

Noctua introduces NA-FG1 fan grills with offset push-pin mounting

Sharkoon M30 Black & M30 RGB | Elegant ATX Cases for Office and Gaming
Cooling Systems

Sharkoon M30 Black & M30 RGB | Elegant ATX Cases for Office and Gaming

Epson Adds 4K Enhancement to Compact and Versatile 5,200 and 7,000 Lumen PowerLite L Series Laser Projectors
Consumer Electronics

Epson Adds 4K Enhancement to Compact and Versatile 5,200 and 7,000 Lumen PowerLite L Series Laser Projectors

ViewSonic's Latest 4K Presentation Displays Harness Video Conferencing AI to Put the Focus on All Meeting Participants
Enterprise & IT

ViewSonic's Latest 4K Presentation Displays Harness Video Conferencing AI to Put the Focus on All Meeting Participants

Envision Enhances Its Range of Smart Glasses For Blind and Low-Vision Communities - Making Them More Accessible For Everyone
Enterprise & IT

Envision Enhances Its Range of Smart Glasses For Blind and Low-Vision Communities - Making Them More Accessible For Everyone

Popular Reviews

Withings Thermo Wi-Fi-connected temporal thermometer

Withings Thermo Wi-Fi-connected temporal thermometer

EnGenius ECW230 Access Point

EnGenius ECW230 Access Point

Withings Body Plus Scale

Withings Body Plus Scale

Withings Sleep Analyzer

Withings Sleep Analyzer

Noctua NH-D12L CPU Cooler

Noctua NH-D12L CPU Cooler

EnGenius ECW230S AP

EnGenius ECW230S AP

Scythe Fuma 2 CPU Cooler

Scythe Fuma 2 CPU Cooler

be quiet! Pure Rock 2 FX

be quiet! Pure Rock 2 FX

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Essays
  • Forum
  • Legacy
  • About
    • Submit News

    • Contact Us
    • Privacy

    • Promotion
    • Advertise

    • RSS Feed
    • Site Map
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Promotional Opportunities @ CdrInfo.com
  • Advertise on out site
  • Submit your News to our site
  • RSS Feed